The Weekly is STREAMING now. Join us at HorizonTV

Incentivizing change: Show me the money

Who is succeeding, and on what terms? And what will it take for everyone to experience the benefits of that success?

Sponsored content
March 15, 2017 |
Sasha Reed

I recently moderated a panel discussion in the UK co-hosted by the CIOB and Construction Manager, where UK BIM managers and consultants from both the UK and US explored the timely question, “The UK BIM Level 2 mandate: was it a success?”

It became clear almost immediately that defining exactly what was meant by “success” was going to be a lot harder than answering the question! “Success” is generally defined as “achieving your goal”—but whose goal are we referring to when it comes to the UK BIM mandate? The UK government’s goal? The building owner’s goal? The contractor and subcontractor’s goals? Every one of these groups views “success” differently. Some might define it as industry-wide compliance, while others see saved time and increased profits as the goal.

So who is succeeding, and on what terms? And what will it take for everyone to experience the benefits of that success?

Let’s start looking at this question by agreeing that the UK BIM mandate will be a success when the building owners, architects, engineers, contractors, subcontractors and facility managers all benefit from implementing the change. There’s no way actual success can be defined as one group profiting while another group suffers.

The truth is, implementing BIM, a system designed to root out and minimize risk, is in fact a risky proposition for many of the groups who are required to implement it. This is because the risk BIM seeks to eliminate has value, especially up front, and that valuation is often left out of the equation. Let’s face it: there is money to be made from taking on that risk.

So I think we need to face the real, underlying challenge head-on, which is to redefine the true value of a project over its total lifespan so everyone can benefit from the increased efficiencies BIM introduces.

The total value of BIM is realized over the lifetime of a building—30+ years. All the relatively short-term value saved up front by sharing data and modeling information during the construction phase gets lumped into the long-term F&M value, which both yield significant savings.

This clearly benefits the building’s owner, should they hold onto the asset or choose to sell at a higher price based on projected long-term profits. So owners might say the BIM Level 2 mandate is succeeding at increasing their bottom line. But the owners aren’t the only ones looking to define success through greater profit. What about the architects and the engineers? The contractors and the subcontractors? How is the BIM mandate going to make them more successful?

For these players, the successful implementation of the BIM mandate can’t be defined as simply sharing data on the jobsite for the benefit of others. As much as we all want to “do the right thing,” the economics of construction are such that compliance means less risk and fewer billable hours. The benefits of working harder on more projects to make the same money doesn’t really seem like progress.

In order for everyone involved to embrace the mandate and take on the mammoth job of implementing new technologies and workflows, the teams taking on the bulk of the work have to be able to experience their fair share of the profits. If the efficiencies create profit over a 30+ year timeframe, then the way building projects are financed needs to change in order to ensure everyone experiences the benefits. Valuing a construction project over the building’s entire lifecycle with the long-term benefits of BIM built into the equation would result in increased capital being made available up front to replace the real-world risk and profit BIM eliminates.  

More money available during the construction phase would reflect the increased value realized over the entire building’s lifespan. BIM implementation could then be rewarded by replacing the profits associated with assuming risk under the old model with profits earned through compliance with the new BIM model.

People need incentives to make changes. It’s human nature. Mandates by themselves may deliver simple compliance, although implementation can be painful and the benefits are often obscured. Bonuses related to boosted performance work, but you can easily end up with uneven results as groups of highly skilled companies emerge that outpace the competition. The combination of both has to be the way forward, leveraging mandates and bonuses together to level the playing field by rewarding increases in productivity on projects that have been appropriately valued.

As for the question we originally proposed, “BIM Level 2 mandate: was it a success?” We’re getting there. Ultimately, people will believe in what works for them. As Fred Mills, Director for The B1M said on the CIOB panel, “Real change is like jumping off a cliff and then trying to build your wings on the way down.”  It’s our job as industry professionals to ensure whatever means and methods are used to deliver on the promise of BIM, everyone benefits equally. And that’s a definition of success we can all agree on. 

Sasha Reed | StrXur by Bluebeam
Bluebeam, Inc.
Vice President of Strategic Development

As Vice President of Strategic Development at Bluebeam, Inc., Sasha Reed collaborates with leaders in the architecture, engineering and construction industry to guide Bluebeam’s technology, partnerships and long-term goals. She joined Bluebeam in 2007 and co-created the Concierge Approach, a distinctly branded process of customer engagement, product feedback and solution delivery to which much of Bluebeam’s success is attributed, and which today is replicated at every organizational level.

Sasha is known industry-wide as a “conversation facilitator,” creating platforms for exchanges necessary to digitally advance the industry, including the BD+C Magazine Digital COM Blog, which she authors and manages. She’s been a featured presenter at numerous national and international conferences, including the 2014 Design-Build Institute of America (DBIA), Federal Project Delivery Symposium and NTI Danish BIM Conference. Sasha also co-chairs the Construction PDF Coalition, a grassroots effort to provide a common industry framework from which to create and maintain construction PDF documents, serves on the City College of San Francisco BIM Industry Council, and is Advisor to the Board of Direction for the National Institute of Building Sciences BuildingSMART Alliance.

Related Blogs

December 15, 2017 | StrXur by Bluebeam

Looking beyond today’s constraints to the possibility of what “could be” is a key characteristic of those d...

November 30, 2017 | BIM and Information Technology | StrXur by Bluebeam

New York’s Tappan Zee Bridge first opened to traffic in 1955.

4 people speaking on a panel
September 19, 2017 | BIM and Information Technology | StrXur by Bluebeam

In this four-part series, Bluebeam VP Sasha Reed sat down with industry experts to examine the need for def...

A hospital under construction
August 28, 2017 | Healthcare Facilities | StrXur by Bluebeam

McCarthy will continue to lean on Bluebeam solutions to help solve the most critical issues, and to keep th...

An exterior shot of the Beijing National Stadium
August 17, 2017 | Building Materials | StrXur by Bluebeam

Lighter than glass and 100% recyclable, one material takes center stage in the future of building.

Rendering of a Matrix-style theater
August 02, 2017 | Architects | StrXur by Bluebeam

An Australian Home Theater Company is out to prove that the easier you can see it, the easier you can sell...

July 19, 2017 | Architects | StrXur by Bluebeam

Our goal is to present unique perspectives you may not be able to find anywhere else.  

July 13, 2017 | Accelerate Live! | StrXur by Bluebeam

From my perspective, what separates organizations thriving in the digital revolution from those who are not...

October 04, 2016 | Building Team | StrXur by Bluebeam

As the construction industry bounces back from the Great Recession, an entirely new class of tech-savvy con...

July 11, 2016 | Building Team | StrXur by Bluebeam

The lead up to AECX featured a discussion providing insight into the current state of the AEC technological...

Overlay Init

Your card will be charged: 0